
Adults like it, but what about the kids?
It would be an obvious statement to say that no one cares about your work as much as you do. I sent three manuscripts to semi-friendly editors. Here are the results:
- One third of the editors responded.
- About half of that one third responded to my follow-up questions.
- For those who have not responded and those who did not reply to my follow-ups, I will not repeat the questions. I decided up front not to be a pest.
- Almost unanimously, one story received very good reviews. Adults like it, some love it. No feedback yet from the editors with kids.
- The other two manuscripts have both received mixed reviews. The reviews for these range from love it, to hate it, to numerous steps in-between.
Ultimately, the reviews have been relatively thorough, constructive and without fluff. That’s a good thing. Don’t let it be said that friends can’t be good reviewers. Some family members had the guts to tell me they wouldn’t be objective reviewers because they think I’m really cool. Well, they’re right, and I appreciate the honesty.
The more experienced writers on a site I shared the “children’s book” with, aren’t as enthusiastic. They basically shot it down as a picture book. I obviously mis-categorized it on that site. Oh well, live, learn and move on.